• Admin

MANUAL SCAVENGING IN INDIA: A HARSH REALITY

Author: Umang Dudeja

IMS Unison University, Dehradun




ABSTRACT

The term 'manual scavenging' refers to the act of carrying human excreta by hand. During the past, this applied to the method of extracting excreta from dry latrines but, during addition, modern sanitation techniques introduced new ways of manual scavenging work, including manual and hazardous drain cleaning, sewage pipes, septic tanks, and latrine pits. The government survey reported 54,130 people engaged in this job as of July 2019, following a 2013 law banning the employment of manual scavengers. The figure is understated, because the survey was conducted only in areas where "there are reasons to assume that manual scavengers exist." The survey was carried out in 170 districts in 18 Member States.[1]

Activists have used the word ‘Safai Karmachari’ to mean manual scavenging as an occupation rather than an ethnicity, but the term ‘safai karmachari’ refers to employees that work as sweepers and sanitation employees, as well as to those who clean excrement manually. In the report we refer to "manual scavenging," because this is the term used in the 2013 Act.

KEYWORDS: Manual Scavenging, Human Rights, Human waste, India’s manual scavenging.


INTRODUCTION

In many parts of South Asia, the tradition of manually cleaning excrements from private and public dry toilets and open drains continues. Throughout most of the part of India, keeping with centuries-old colonial and caste-based practice, women from societies historically employed as "manual scavengers" still gather human waste on a regular basis, load it into cane baskets or metal troughs and bring it away on their heads for disposal at the outskirts of the town.

After independence in 1947, India's central government has adopted legislative and policy efforts to end manual scavenging. They include efforts to modernize sanitation in recent years, such that no more need is made for the manual disposal of feces, and prohibitions on employing others to do this work. Since these policies are not properly enforced, however, people remain unsure of their right to refuse this position, and those who refuse may face extreme social pressure, including violence and threats and expulsion from their village, often with the involvement of local government officers.

Manual scavengers are typically relegated to the bottom of the caste hierarchy from caste classes and restricted to livelihood tasks regarded by higher caste classes as deplorable or considered too menial. A caste-designated profession strengthens the social stigma of being unclean or "untouchable," and continues widespread discrimination. People typically clean dry toilets, women and men clean excrement from open sites of ejaculation, gutters, and drains, and are required to do the more physically demanding sewage cleaning and sewerage systems job.

There are constitutional and statutory prohibitions in India on "untouchability" and “manual scavenging”. Women and men have to manually clean up human excrements from private and public dry toilets, open defecation areas, septic tanks and open and closed canals and sewers. They typically embark on manual scavenging due to conventional caste-based positions that leave them with few, if any, alternative job choices, a condition perpetuated by weak laws and policies that ban this activity.


SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC PRESSURE

Women engaged in manual scavenging face community and family pressure to continue this profession, since their households have few other livelihood options. These are also India's poorest and most disadvantaged societies, where even food security is a big challenge. Although men can work as day labourers from manual scavenger societies, their income is unreliable. Without access to consistent income, families rely on women's daily food handouts for survival.[2]

Women and men working by local government panchayats and Municipal Corporations as sanitation workers have said that; they are doing this job because they have no other means of subsistence. [3]

Women who practice manual scavenging have told Human Rights Watch that because dry toilets are cleaned regularly, when they miss even a day, they face pressure from the group. Anita, who cleans dry toilets in the village of Kasela in the district of Etah, Uttar Pradesh, said there has been no intervention to stop manual scavenging and prevailing castes are forcing her to continue the practice:

“I did not clean the toilets for just one day. They came to my house and told me, if you do not come, we will throw you out of the village. You will have nowhere to go”.[4]

Human Rights Watch interviewed women around Madhya Pradesh who had abandoned scavenging manuals between 2002 and 2009. Most indicated that people would come to their homes regularly after they left, threatening them, and demanding that the work be resumed. Yashodabai, from Dharia Khedi village in Mandsaur district, Madhya Pradesh said, “For a year after I stopped doing this work, everyday people would come to my home and demand that I clean their toilets.


A DEADLY OCCUPATION

The number of people killed when sewers and septic tanks were being cleaned has risen in recent years. 2019 saw the largest number of deaths from manual scavenging in the last 5 years. 110 Employees were killed when sewage and septic tanks were being washed. It is a rise of 61 per cent compared to 2018, which has seen 68 cases of related deaths. The Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers and Their Rehabilitation Act placed an end to any sort of manual waste cleaning, transport, disposal, or handling operation in 2013.

Nevertheless, according to a National survey carried out in 18 States, more than 50,000 manual scavengers were reported until 31 January 2020 and according to data obtained in 2018, 29,923 people are involved in manual scavenging in Uttar Pradesh, making it the maximum in any state in India.[5]

Deaths of 814 manual scavengers engaged in sewer and septic tank cleaning were recorded in 20 states and UTs in India from 1993 to July 2019. Of these 20 States, only 11 States have details of the compensation received by the family of the deceased. This suggests the likelihood of under reporting in the number of known manual scavengers and the number of fatalities. Tamil Nadu had reported 206 deaths of manual scavengers who cleaned sewers and septic tanks between 1993 and July 2019 out of the total deaths. It was the best of all Countries. Gujarat reported 156 deaths of that sort, the second highest.

Six people died in Sriperumbudur in March from asphyxiation after inhaling poisonous fumes while cleaning a septic tank. Similarly, seven people died of asphyxiation in February 2018 when they were cleaning a private septic tank in Chittoor. Five people lost their lives in a septic tank in a remote village of Chhattisgarh, and five others died the same month while cleaning a sewer near DLF flats in Delhi's Moti Nagar area.[6]

This trend is not new. This is, the on-ground reality right from the start, in truth.

There are multiple deaths in more than 82 percent of such events, suggesting that they are not simply accidents but instances of lack of systematic execution. They are refused access to the equipment required by the Supreme Court, during their suffocating work. Workers lose their lives attempting to help their stuck colleagues while fighting the toxic fumes in the gas chambers themselves which are septic tanks. Their contributions only underscore the State's indifference.


THE EMPLOYMENT OF MANUAL SCAVENGERS AND CONSTRUCTION OF DRY LATRINES (PROHIBITION) ACT, 1993

This legislation made the use of "scavengers" or the building of dry toilets punishable with imprisonment for up to a year and a fine of Rs.2000 subject to an increase of Rs.100 per day for repeated violations.